Cheap Hotels in Shelter Island
Free cancellation options if plans change
Unlock travel rewards with One Key
Save more with Member Prices
Check prices for these dates
Cheap Hotels in Shelter Island
Clinton Motel
Top neighborhoods in Shelter Island
Silver Beach
Shelter Island's Silver Beach neighborhood offers attractions including Shell Beach.
Coecles Harbor
Shelter Island's Coecles Harbor neighborhood offers attractions including Menhadden Lane Beach.
Menantic Creek
Shorewood
Shelter Island's Shorewood neighborhood offers attractions including Wades Beach.
Hay Beach
Shelter Island's Hay Beach neighborhood offers attractions including Menhadden Lane Beach.
Top landmarks in Shelter Island
Shelter Island Historical Society
If museums are on your list of things to see in Shelter Island, then you might want to head to Shelter Island Historical Society. If you want to see more of the museums in Shelter Island, you can easily walk to Havens House.
Mashomack Preserve
Mashomack Preserve is 1.3 mi (2.1 km) from central Shelter Island, why not stop by during your stay. Want to stretch your legs some more? Head to Foster Memorial Town Beach and Cedar Point County Park, both nearby.
Frequently asked questions
Find out more about Shelter Island
How to find the best cheap hotels in Shelter Island?
✅ There are lots of cheap hotels available in Shelter Island in 2026. What's more, our rewards programOpens in a new window makes Shelter Island hotels an even better choice for travelers on a budget.
✅ Whether you're looking for a hostel, apart-hotel or Bed & Breakfast, there's something for every type of traveler in Shelter Island on Hotels.com – use the helpful search filters to find some of the cheapest hotels in Shelter Island for your budget-friendly stay.
✅ You'll find lots of cheap hotels in Shelter Island – with Hotels.com. With so many choices, we recommend you use the search filter for price limits to narrow down your options.
✅ The best time of year for an affordable vacation to Shelter Island is during low season. This is when fewer people visit and there is a wider range of cheap Shelter Island hotels available.
✅ There are plenty of things to see and do in Shelter Island on a budget! From exploring the city's iconic landmarks and museums to enjoying the great outdoors and local parks, there is something for everyone in Shelter Island.
✅ If you're looking to travel to Shelter Island on a budget, there are plenty of ways to save. One option is to consider booking your travel during off-peak times when prices for flights, hotels, and attractions may be lower. Another option is budget-friendly transportation, such as local public transportation like buses or trains.
✅ To find the great budget hotels in Shelter Island for families, use our "Family friendly" filter under the "Travel experience" header. This will filter for family-friendly accommodation essentials.
*Prices and availability are subject to change. Additional terms may apply.